What a Sad Night in Bethlehem
I just saw The Nativity Story with my family. Now, before I say anything, I do realize that sometimes things get sacrificed for the sake of story; things like accuracy get set aside in the name of creativity and expectations. I thought the story was great. It explored the relationships between Joseph and Mary and their smalltown home; the relationship between Mary and Elizabeth. I thought the Magi sub-plot was good as well, except for the part where they arrive at the stable. I read an interview with the screenplay writer (who is quite aware of the potential backlash from that) who mentioned that the public expectation would be to have a scene like the pop-up nativity scenes on our coffee tables this time of year.
No, my beef is not with those things (although it could be). My beef is this: in a culture rife with celebrations, there was only one smile in the whole movie. One. Everyone is so sad. There is no joy in this event at all, not even when the angel announces the birth to the shepherds. Now I realize that those were hard times, but even in Fiddler on the Roof there are celebrations and moments of joy in the midst of the struggles. This, though, was a sad, lonely, heavy movie that left me feeling like someone died.
If you plan to see the movie with your family, anyone under 10 will probably get bored after 15 minutes.
